Who do you blame for your birth trauma?

This is a question I have asked myself many times and each time I tend to get a different answer, depending on my mood. At first, and on many other occasions since, I blamed the hospital. I must stress here that ‘the hospital’ is not the staff (not all of them anyway) but more the red tape, rules and lack of funds leading to bad decisions and busy midwives. Naturally, I moved on to blaming myself- if I had stamped my foot harder I would’ve got my elective section when it mattered and the whole trauma would not have occurred. But that only leads me back to blaming the hospital because they should’ve  been in a position to offer counselling/ serious thought to the vulnerable pregnant woman.

The more I look at it, the more I am forced to just accept it. Yes, lots of things went wrong, mistakes were made and hearts were broken. I can’t change that. I never made a complaint, believing- wrongly, I am told- that if I was to be awarded compensation, that would only make the problem worse for a hospital that is already struggling to provide adequate care. But then I am told that my complaint could help others… could stop the same thing happening again. Whether it would or not, I think its too late.

I never wanted monetary compensation. I would’ve swapped all the money in the world for some understanding. For an apology. For someone to tell me they cared about what happened. For someone to explain, truthfully, what went wrong. For someone to take away the nightmares and the anxiety and that cold, hard ball of fear that rested in my stomach day in and day out. That would’ve been priceless.

So who do I blame? When I was interviewed by the BBC I stated that I blame the hospital for what happened but what I really meant what I blame the system. The NHS, I suppose. I’m entitled to quality care and I just didn’t get it. Not because anyone was particularly negligent, more because they just couldn’t give it to me.

They were forced to deny me an elective section because they cost a lot of money. They were forced to leave me alone for hours because there was nobody available to help me- it was a Sunday and they didn’t have enough staff on duty. They were forced to send me home with a broken body and no pain relief because budgets would not allow them to do otherwise. Never mind I was in agony…

I never really blamed the midwives- in fact, my interview was part of a Royal College of Midwive’s appeal for more midwives in the NHS. There is a severe shortage and it is affecting people like me, families like mine.

But mistakes were made. For which no apology has been given. For which, no apology has been sought.

Am I right or wrong? Am I now in a position to seek out that apology, or explanation? Next week myself and another birth trauma survivor are hosting the Birth Trauma Association’s first support group in Manchester. Caroline’s story was printed in the Manchester Evening News yesterday and today Deanna Delamotta has written a piece about it. It’s interesting that she chose to comment on the fact that Caroline has never sought compensation for what happened.

For so many women who have been through a traumatic birth (and its estimated that around 7,000 women in the UK feel traumatised by birth each year) it is hardly ever about the money. It is always about being listened to. Somebody accepting that mistakes were made and things need to be done differently again. It’s about hospitals improving their care for other women.

So who do I blame? I blame the hospital for the things they did wrong. I blame myself for not standing firm and insisting on the birth I wanted. I blame the consultant for not recognising I needed support when I asked for a c-section. I blame the hospital for changing the surgery dates and not explaining why. I blame the midwives for not listening to me, or taking me seriously. I blame the hospital for cutting budgets which meant I was discharged too early and with no pain relief after labouring and enduring a horrific c-section.  Mostly, I blame fate. Childbirth is such a tricky thing you see. Nobody can predict what will happen. And what will be, will be.




* If you are local to Manchester and would like to come along to the Birth Trauma Association’s support group, our first meeting is taking place next week, Wed 25th April at 3.30-5 pm. Location: Pannone Solicitors Manchester 123 Deansgate, Manchester M3 2BU


9 responses to “Who do you blame for your birth trauma?

  • TheBoyandMe

    I think I have to just accept it, but I can’t because I’m still so angry. At the heart of it I blame two people. I blame my GP for not picking up my pre-existing conditions, both of which meant that The Boy should have been a c-section. She actually told me once that she didn’t have time to look up my details and find out what I was going on about. Had she investigated the fractured pubic bone, she’d have realised that could have caused his shoulder distocia! I secondly blame the consultant in the room who didn’t say, “Stop! We need to do a c-section on this lady and her baby now!”, who misplaced the forceps denting his skull, and who yanked him out ripping me apart.

    Coincidentally, they are husband and wife.

    • ghostwritermummy

      Yes, where obvious mistakes have been made like that, you are certainly entitled to blame specific people. I blame my consultant too as he convinced me Luka would be too small for an elective section and made me feel awful for wanting one, even hinting towards SCBU just for being born early. He was 7lb 7! Isobel was born early by elective and she was small- 5lb 15 so not teeny-tiny- but perfectly healthy. Many more things went wrong but this is where it started for me. THanks for your comment, hope you’re ok

  • Maureen

    That is such a moving piece! It is a dilemma that will resonate with many of us.

    I guess at the end of the day, whether we choose to complain, seek compensation or jaccept it, is a personal choice. The main thing is that we do all we can to prevent trauma happening in the first place.

    On that note, lots and lots of luck for your meeting in Manchester! Keep us posted. xxx

  • Kelly Innes (@domesticgoddesq)

    It’s impossible, isn’t it? I was desperate for someone to blame, am desperate for someone to blame, for the fact that I can still not talk about my last birth without tears, and yet no-one really is to blame…but still, I would love to be able to have one face to stick up on a metaphorical dart board.

  • Leah Emily A Payne

    for my first born i was left to push for three hours i was clearly not coping but they carried on. afterwards i was in hospital for ten days as he has a blood infection wich they blamed me for doing for not getting him out but if this was the case should they have got him out quicker??
    your right its not the money your after for me it would have been a ‘your right it is our fault and we are truely sorry for your stress and worry’
    and again it isnt all of the midwives it was lack of funds to help me they had to get me to push him out as they couldnt take me to get a c-section as they didnt have the staff available for it.
    my second baby was at the same hospital and had to be a c-section due to placenta previa and the birth was amazing it was the care before hand that again set me off again all because they didnt have the staff to help me through what was happening.

  • mrsebomac

    For me the answer is simple. I needed to be told what was going on instead of so many doctors rushing in and rushing me off to theatre leaving me with the only resonating thought “my baby is dying”.
    Just a few words, just some explanation. That is all. It could’ve saved me hours of therapy and heartache.
    I will never seek apologies or compensation as I could not bare to revisit these feelings in depth ever again.
    I am just thankful that my health team during my second birth recognised my agony and gave me so much support.
    But the pain still lingers on.

  • Claire T (@needaphone)

    OOh gosh birth truama where do I start .. hence one of the reasons why i only have one ..

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: